I Would Like To Suggest Stronger Moderation Policies

Discussion in 'Suggestions and Requests' started by Ystranc, Jul 22, 2017.

I Would Like To Suggest Stronger Moderation Policies 4 5 1votes
4/5, 1 vote

  1. Ystranc

    Ystranc Well-Known Member
      97/115

    Blog Posts:
    0
    After a recent rash of posts with topics ranging from the rapture to body image I'm finding the material on survival and survival techniques has been lost somewhere along the way.
    I understand that some people feel the need to connect with others but it has passed beyond that to the point where threads are being duplicated and filled with inane comments.
    I'm actually waiting for some fool to post a thread entitled "what's your favorite colour."

    I'm also finding a great many people are posting information that they are making up as they go along, recently there was someone trying to create the rule of 4 because the accepted version (the rule of 3) didn't seem enough for him. He was claiming that the average person can manage 4 minutes without air, 4 hours without shelter, 4 days without water and 4 weeks without food...THIS INFORMATION WAS WRONG! and was patently foolish and dangerous advice, Misinformation can get people killed. Please stick to what you know, if you're not sure just ask or do some research
     
  2. Keith H.

    Keith H. Moderator Staff Member
      345/460

    Blog Posts:
    7
    There are some forums I am no longer following, they were just filling up my email & the posts are just not worth reading.
    Keith.
     
    lonewolf likes this.
  3. Ystranc

    Ystranc Well-Known Member
      97/115

    Blog Posts:
    0
    He who knows not, and knows not that he knows not, is a fool, shun him; He who knows not, and knows that he knows not, is a child, teach him. He who knows, and knows not that he knows, is asleep, wake him. He who knows, and knows that he knows, is wise, follow him.
    (Persian proverb)
     
  4. TexDanm

    TexDanm Expert Member
      242/345

    Blog Posts:
    1
    Ignorance is bliss until it is exposed. Only a fool refuses to ask to alleviate their ignorance; and only a bigger fool mocks and disparages a question from one seeking knowledge.

    East Texas saying...
     
  5. Ystranc

    Ystranc Well-Known Member
      97/115

    Blog Posts:
    0
    Very well TexDanm, what's your favorite colour? :D

    I don't mock people on this forum who I consider to be genuinely seeking information about survivalism or prepping. I will however point out when someone is bullshitting, offering dangerous and illegal advice or trolling another member without even bothering to properly read the post that they're criticising. If they then try and troll me I will cheerfully tell them to fuck off and die.

    I don't give a rats ass what age, sex, colour or creed a person is...I'm not interested in playing favourites. I don't care if they're ex university, military, blue collar, still in school or absolutely unemployable as long as they use the brain in their head when they're writing something that they expect me to take notice of. I can try to correct a mistake or misinformation, I wouldn't try to correct others opinions and I can't do anything at all about bloody minded stupidity.

    To put it simply, if this forum is allowed to fill up with misinformation and mistakes they will continue to circulate on the internet...probably killing and injuring future generations of Darwin Award candidates.
     
  6. TexDanm

    TexDanm Expert Member
      242/345

    Blog Posts:
    1
    I like blue. I also agree about bullcrud and am very aware of the danger of misinformation. But ignorance is hard to tell from stupidity a lot of time. I have a lot of patience for ignorance as long as they are seeking to alleviate it. Stupidity I pity because for them there is no hope. The people that annoy me at the ignorant that seem to be proud of their ignorance and the ones that feign ignorance just so they can annoy people.

    We seem to have a few of those on board right now. I suspect that some of them are borderline autistic and just have no social skills but others may be just doing it for fun. If someone ONLY makes negative posts they expose themselves and that is what moderators are for. Being annoying on the other hand is just the way some people are at times. I KNOW that at times I annoy people but I don't do iy on purpose; I just don't always express myself in the most genteel fashion. Also manners and speech patterns and bluntness vary greatly from place to place.

    One of the things that the internet has exposed is that there are a lot of people that are closet Nillests. They love to tear down anything that others want to build. They can do this on the net because they are anonymous and don't get their buttocks kicked like they would out in the real world. I think that the human species needs a period of survival of the fittest to eliminate these people. In a real world they will have "accidents" if they won't work with the tribe. There won't be many opportunities for them to play their sick games and so eventually they will get caught and eliminated.

    If a person continually starts fights and disagreements in my group and makes everyone work harder because they always seem to be pulling to wrong way in every effort I will tend to the problem myself. These people are like a mad dog. You don't chase a dog with rabies away. You don't want them out there spreading their disease or coming back to bite you in the back of your legs.

    One of the reasons that I feel pretty sure that some sort of collapse is coming is because our current culture has not just allowed these people to survive and thrive; we almost seem to encourage them. Every generation has more and more sick destructive people and in the way we educate and entertain our kids we almost teach them this sick stuff. So many of the video games are about the glory of being violent and antisocial. Criminals and thugs are heroes now. The messages in so many of the things that are called music now are sick and violent.

    For me it is hard to see separating people and understanding them from survival since in a TEOTWAWKI situation other people will be both our biggest threat and our only hope for a life again about more than just living another day.

    If I have annoyed you I'm truly sorry and had no intention to do so.
     
    Tumbleweed likes this.
  7. TexDanm

    TexDanm Expert Member
      242/345

    Blog Posts:
    1
    PS: I am a writer and so typing is for me little more taxing than talking so my posts tend to be longer. I know that this is also annoying to some people but on the flip side I hate twitter and such because the short quips are uninformative and boring to me.
     
    1. Ystranc
      I tend to write far too much and then edit with a heavy hand. I try hard to be clear and concise but I have to work at it. I'm not a natural writer.
       
      Ystranc, Jul 27, 2017
  8. Tumbleweed

    Tumbleweed Active Member
      33/58

    Blog Posts:
    0
    I know that I am new here, too; but I would be willing to help with moderation if I can. I know that it has to be a difficult job because people all have their own lives to take care of, and the moderators can't always be here to catch it when someone makes one of those senseless (or dangerous) posts.
    I helped moderate on a similar forum, and what we did was read the posts of each new person every day for up to the first week. If they wrote silly posts, the posts were deleted, and the writer was warned. If they continued to write something that did not add value to the forum, then they were banned.
    I am a senior lady, and I am home most of the time, and would have the time to help with a project like this if it would make the forum work better again. There has to be a line between not getting any new members, and getting a whole bunch of useless ones that just post for the sake of writing something.
     
    Ystranc likes this.
    1. Ystranc
      Tumbleweed, you have a wise head on your shoulders and I respect everything you've posted so far. You would be so much better at moderating than me.
       
      Ystranc, Jul 27, 2017
      Tumbleweed likes this.
Loading...
Similar Threads Forum Date
Again May I Suggest Suggestions and Requests Wednesday at 8:17 PM
May I Suggest General Q&A Jul 30, 2017
What? No Battery Suggestions??? Going Off The Grid Jul 15, 2017
Mojave Desert Bow Drill Material Suggestions All Resources About Fire Dec 17, 2016
MRE suggestions? Finding, Identifying, and Preparing Food May 19, 2016
Suggested Courses for Mental Preparedness Mental Preparedness Jan 21, 2016
Cooking Method Suggestions Finding, Identifying, and Preparing Food Jan 20, 2016
Any suggestions for harvesting rain water? Finding, Purifying, and Storing Water Jan 19, 2016

Share This Page